Tag Archives: Smartest Guys In The Room

Alex Gibney To Direct Movie About Julian Assange

Oscar-winning director Alex Gibney (Enron: The Smartest Guys in the Room, Client 9: The Rise and Fall of Eliot Spitzer) will direct a documentary about WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange, funded by Universal.

Gibney’s style of moviemaking is akin to Michael Moore’s. His films lack even a pretense of objectivity. In the case of The Smartest Guys In The Room, Gibney did not even bother to tell an actual coherent story; he was content to pander to Enron haters by simply stringing together nonsensical images that bore no relation to one another. He spliced in recreations, manipulated the timeline, and otherwise tried his level best to create a story, truth be damned.

I sense he will be much more kind to Julien Assange, but time will tell (unlike his ability to tell time.)

Leave a Comment

Filed under Enron

Bethany McLean To Discuss Smartest Guys – Again

Bethany McLean will be giving a talk about The Smartest Guys In The Room on November 30, 2009 from 11:00 a.m. – 12:00 p.m. at Miller Center ( 2201 Old Ivy Rd., Charlottesville VA 22904).

If you attend, please report back. I’m curious if she has anything else to talk about or if she’s just going to ride Enron’s coattails for the next fifty years.

2 Comments

Filed under Enron

Today In Enron History

The day before, Bethany McLean had interviewed Jeff Skilling for an article she was writing for Fortune Magazine. In the interview, Bethany began to get into some issues that Skilling was not – at that exact moment- prepared to talk about. “I have six minutes,” he said, “before I have to be in another meeting.” But he volunteered to send accountants and other finance executives to New York to help Bethany understand how Enron made its money. Bethany replied that she was going to run the story with or without his help and Jeff replied that he believed it was unethical to run the story without allowing Enron a chance to answer the questions McLean was raising. Bethany accused Skilling of then saying that Fortune only wanted to “throw rocks at the company.”

On February 15, 2001, Mark Palmer, head of publicity for Enron, and CFO Andrew Fastow flew to New York. In Smartest Guys In The Room Bethany complains that they were in a small, dark conference room – though they were in her office, and ostensibly she could have found a more suitable place for the meeting. She says that at the end of the two-hour meeting, as others were packing up to go, Andy Fastow said to her, “I don’t care what you say about the company. Just don’t make me look bad.”

Since Bethany McLean is the only source for the quote, it’s difficult to take seriously.  Like the “throwing rocks” comment, these remarks don’t sound like the people they are attributed to.

Oddly, Bethany McLean has never revealed what was said about the company in that meeting, and if Mark Palmer and Andy Fastow were any help in clarifying her confusion over Enron.  Like most of Bethany’s career, the substance just manages to get… left behind.

Leave a Comment

Filed under Enron

Ask Cara Ellison

Dear Cara,
I am the wife of a pastor. My husband is a wonderful man but sometimes he makes me want to pull my hair out! He performs about forty weddings a year and he has a habit of giving a small gift to every couple for whom he performs a wedding. My problem is that he always gives the same gift! I say that if he knows the couple well, like if they are long-time congregants at the church, he should go ahead and splurge a little. I feel its a little disrespectful to give them the same gift he gives the couples he’s known only months. He says he’s comfortable giving his usual gift. Cara, who is right?
– A Loving Pastor’s Wife In Loving, Alabama

The problems with The Smartest Guys In The Room, I think, begin in the very origin of the movie. Director Alex Gibney once said himself that he’s fascinated with the “space” in between fact and fiction, and this movie really reflects that. His idea of ‘documentary’ includes fiction precepts – rumor and innuendo – such as mark to marketing fraud, Jeff Skilling’s supposed arrogance, and Dr. Lay’s alleged cluelessness. Even when the facts are easily available, Gibney chooses to ignore them in favor of his more scandalous (and incorrect) interpretation.

Dear Cara,
I am a twenty-four year old man with a three-year old son. My wife left me and its been only the boy and me for a few years now. I met a nice woman at the grocery store where I work and I’d like to ask her out, but I don’t think she knows about my son. Should I tell her about my son before I ask her out or would that be presumptuous?

–Stumped and Still Single In Fargo

You wanna hear about stumped? How about the allegation that Jeff Skilling was anything less than a conscientious executive. Let’s start there. The man spent a decade of his life working for Enron, and years before that working at McKinsey on the Enron account. He knew the company backward and forward, and he loved it. In Conspiracy of Fools, Eichenwald relates the story that Jeff Skilling accepted the Enron position the morning his son was born. If this is true, I think it reinforces what some of us already know about the man: he never stopped working for Enron. Even at the most special time of his life, he was thinking about that company. And this is how shareholders repay him! With allegations! With vitriol! It’s outrageous and I am completely aghast that anyone would besmirch this man’s reputation. Shame on you! SHAME ON YOU!

Dear Cara,
My new boss has sent me an invitation for an informal barbecue. My problem is, I can’t decide what the dress code is for such an occasion. Should I “dress to impress” or go with the flow in a casual sundress? Help!
– Quandry in Quebec

You want to know what to wear, I say you look at Bethany McLean, and do the exact opposite. At Jeff Skilling’s trial she was dressed in ridiculous haute couture costumes, which is completely inappropriate for a reporter at a trial. Also, her hair was really greasy. Frankly the bitch needed a shower. And I find that I need a shower after reading any of her preposterous anti-Enron tirades since she has no clue what she’s talking about. Is Enron Overpriced? No. No it wasn’t. But Bethany McLean is overrated.

2 Comments

Filed under Uncategorized