Catcalls Turn Women Into Crybabies
CNN posted an article about the impact of catcalls on women. Holly Kearl, a master’s candidate in Women’s Studies, conducted an email survey of 225 women on the subject. She found that 98 percent of respondents experienced some form of “street harassment.”
A few thoughts immediately spring to mind. The first is, if somebody sends me an email and asks if I’ve ever been a victim of “street harassment”, I probably would not even bother to hit reply and ask, “What do you mean by ’street harrassment’?” I’d simply hit delete. In other words, it seems like the only kind of people who would respond are those who feel victimized in this way. I’m not sure this is, strictly speaking, good research. But it gets better: the definition of street harassment: “For me, anyone who interrupts my personal space to objectify me or make me feel uncomfortable or threatened is harassing me,” says Holly Kearl.
Oh lordy. I assume she’s sworn off the New York subway. That will make you feel uncomfortable. And probably objectified. And threatened. But anyway, what sort of guy “interrupts personal space” to catcall women? Don’t they tend to just do that from construction sites? Or do they walk right up to the woman and say something? The CNN article quotes a woman who made a documentary film on the subject who says that when confronted, some of the men literally ran away. So which set of information is true?
But this is a serious issue: the mere feeling of impending doom is enough to be victimized? Don’t women have an obligation to be strong enough of mind to ignore the ramblings of strangers?
Catcalls are generally compliments - not threats - so what law is being violated? What would Kearl propose happen to men (or women) who say something to somebody who doesn’t necessarily want to hear it?
I recoil at stories like this because the bottom line is always impinging on someone else’s freedom. Even if he’s a jackass he has the right to yell in the street - just like homeless people who haven’t taken their medication, or a couple arguing before dinner. To be offended or feel victimized by this is to show an enormous lack of sophistication about the world. If this offends you, volunteer at the pediatric burn unit at your local hospital. Then tell me you feel like life is unfair because somebody yelled “hey blondie!” outside the window of a battered red pickup.
Still, if they insist on being hurt by something so minor, inconsequential, and meaningless as this, I suggest that next time somebody yells from a construction site, keep walking.
Filed under: Nanny-State | Tagged: women | 9 Comments »
